Six years after Alexis Bledel reprised her iconic Gilmore Girls role on the show’s Netflix revival—and left viewers hanging over her character’s pregnancy after it was revealed in the last seconds of the series finale—fans are still searching for answers as to who fathered the littlest Gilmore. In fact, the constant questions surrounding the mystery has led Valerie Campbell, a costume supervisor who worked on Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, to set the record straight once and for all.